My divorced neighbor told me, “I’m going to steal your husband, so you might as well start preparing for divorce…
Maddie looked at the box.
“Mom,” she said. “What’s in there?”
“A pie,” I said. “And a few other things.”
“Are you going to make a scene?”
I thought about it.
“Not the kind you think,” I said.
Maddie looked at me for a long moment. Then she nodded.
“Can I come?”
“No,” I said. “This is between me and her.”
“Mom.” She put her hand on my arm. “Whatever happens. I’m proud of you.”
I walked into Vanessa’s backyard at four fifty-five.
Uninvited.
I didn’t knock. I just opened the gate in the fence between our yards and walked through it. Carrying a large white gift box with a blue ribbon.
The conversations around me slowly stopped.
It happened in a wave. First the Pratts, who were standing closest to the gate. Then the Johnsons by the grill. Then the people at the long table with the white tablecloth. One by one, they turned around and looked at me.
The soft jazz kept playing on the speaker. That was the only sound.
Vanessa was standing by the drink cooler with Irvin. She had her hand on his arm. She was laughing at something.
She saw me.
Her laugh stopped. Her hand dropped off Irvin’s arm.
Her smile tightened. It didn’t go away. It just got very stiff, like it had been painted on.
“Janet,” she said. Her voice was bright and sharp. “What are you doing here?”
I walked across the yard toward her. Slowly. I could feel every pair of eyes following me.
Irvin stepped away from her. He came and stood next to me. Right next to me. Shoulder to shoulder. He didn’t say anything. He just stood there.
I stopped in front of the long table with the white tablecloth.
“I brought the hostess a gift,” I said.
I set the box down on the table in front of her.
“Go ahead,” I said. “Open it.”
Vanessa looked at the box. She looked at me. She looked around at the neighbors. Twenty-five people. All of them watching her.
She couldn’t say no. Not in front of everyone. Not at her own party.
She smiled her stiff smile.
“How sweet,” she said.
She pulled the blue ribbon. It came loose and fell on the tablecloth. She lifted the lid.
On top, wrapped in a clean dish towel, there was the peach pie. With the lattice top. She looked at it. For a second, her face softened. She remembered.
“Oh,” she said. “It’s the pie. The same pie.”
Then she moved the pie to the side.
Underneath it, there was the clear plastic bag.
The notes. The pink one with the heart. The printed text messages. The stale chocolate chip cookies in their ziplock bag. The unopened bottle of wine. The chemistry book in its bookstore bag with the receipt.
Every single thing she had given my husband.
Vanessa stared at it.
Her smile vanished.
The neighbors closest to the table leaned forward to look. Mrs. Pratt put her hand over her mouth. I heard somebody whisper, “Are those love notes?”
I didn’t say anything. I didn’t read them out loud. I didn’t hold them up. I didn’t need to.
Vanessa’s face went red. Then white. Her hand came up to her throat.
“He gave you these,” she whispered.
“Every single one,” I said quietly. “The day after you got them. He kept them in a shoebox in our garage. He never ate the cookies. He never drank the wine. He never opened the book.” I looked at her. “He didn’t want to hurt your feelings. That’s the kind of man he is. He just kept saying no and putting everything in the box. In case I ever needed to know he wasn’t hiding anything from me.”
Vanessa looked at Irvin.
Irvin looked back at her. Calm. Kind. Not angry.
“I’m sorry, Vanessa,” he said. “I should have said something sooner. I didn’t know how.”
She looked away from him. She looked down at the box again.
There was one more thing in it. At the very bottom. Wrapped in white tissue paper.
She didn’t want to touch it. I could see it in her face. But everybody was watching. She had to.
She reached into the box. She lifted out the package. She peeled back the white tissue paper.
A white leather photo album. With gold letters on the cover.
Vanessa & Mark. June 14, 2008.
And the color drained from her face.
She didn’t scream. She didn’t throw it. She didn’t run.
She just stood there holding her own wedding album. Her hands started to shake.
“Where,” she said. Her voice was barely a whisper. “Where did you get this?”
“From your garage,” I said. “The day you moved in. When I was helping you unpack. It was in a box next to the garbage cans. The box said DUMP.” I paused. “I took it. Just that. Nothing else. I thought someday you might want it back.”
Vanessa stared at me.
“Why?” she said. “Why would you do that?”
“Because my mother threw away every picture of my father when he left,” I said. “And she spent the last ten years of her life asking me if I had any.” I looked at the album in her hands. “I didn’t. I wished I had. So I kept yours. Just in case.”
Around us, nobody moved. Nobody spoke. The soft jazz was still playing. Somebody’s kid was crying by the fence, and his mother was shushing him without looking away.
Vanessa opened the album.
The first page. The young woman in the white dress in front of the church, laughing with her head tipped back.
She looked at it for a long time.
Then she turned to the last page. To the photo slipped in later. The barbecue. The picnic table. The blond woman with her hand on Mark’s arm. Us & the Carlsons. Labor Day 2019. Best neighbors ever!
Vanessa made a sound. A small sound. Like something breaking inside her.
There was one more thing in the album. A card. Cream-colored, with little blue flowers around the edge. Just like her invitation. I’d bought it at the same store. I’d slipped it inside the back cover.
She took it out with shaking fingers. She opened it.
I’d written it three times before I got it right.
Vanessa,
I know what he said to you. In your kitchen. When you came home early. “Men get bored after that many years. You should have seen it coming.”
I know because you said the exact same words to me. In my kitchen.
I don’t think you believed them. I think you just needed somebody else to feel the way you felt that day.
I’m not going to let you take my husband. But I’m also not going to do to you what Kristen Carlson did.
You don’t have to be her. You don’t have to be the neighbor who takes. You can be the one who brings a pie.
The pie’s still warm. My door’s still open.
— Janet
She read it.
She read it again.
Then Vanessa Hale sat down on the grass in the middle of her own backyard barbecue, in her short red sundress, with her wedding album in her lap, in front of twenty-five neighbors.
And she started to cry.
It was terrible. And it was quiet. That was the strange part. She didn’t sob or wail. She just sat there with her head bowed over the album and her shoulders shaking, and the tears ran down her face and dropped onto the white leather cover.
Nobody knew what to do. The neighbors looked at each other. Somebody’s husband started to say something and his wife elbowed him.
I knelt down on the grass next to her.
I didn’t plan to. I didn’t decide to. I just did. The same way you’d kneel down next to a child who fell off a bike.
“Vanessa,” I said. “Let’s go inside.”
She shook her head.
“Everybody saw,” she whispered. “Everybody saw everything.”
“I know,” I said. “So let’s go inside. Away from everybody.”
I stood up. I held out my hand.
She looked up at me for a long moment. Her mascara was running down her face in black streaks.
She took my hand.
I pulled her up. I put my arm around her shoulders. I walked her across her own backyard, through all those staring neighbors, past the grill and the long table and the little white lights, and into her house.
Behind me, I heard Irvin’s voice. Calm and clear.
“Okay, everybody,” he said. “Who wants a burger? I’ll take over the grill. Mrs. Kowalski, I believe you wanted a cheeseburger, medium-well?”
The music kept playing. And slowly, slowly, the party started again.
We sat at her kitchen table. The same table where we’d unpacked dishes on her first day. Surrounded by boxes that were long gone now.
I made her a cup of tea. She had a whole drawer of fancy teas. I picked chamomile.
She held the cup with both hands. She didn’t drink it. She stared into it.
“I don’t know who I am anymore,” she said finally.
I didn’t say anything. I just waited.
“Fifteen years,” she said. “Fifteen years I was married to Mark. I thought we were happy. We had a house. A good life. Barbecues. Neighbors. Kristen and Dan Carlson. We did everything with them. Labor Day. Fourth of July. Christmas Eve.” She laughed. It wasn’t a real laugh. “Kristen was my best friend. My best friend. She helped me pick out paint colors. She held my hand when my dad died.”
She wiped her face with a napkin.
“And then I came home early from a sales trip,” she said. “Two days early. To surprise him. Kristen’s car was in my driveway. And they were in my kitchen. At my table. And she was wearing my robe.”
I put my hand over my mouth.
“Mark didn’t even look sorry,” Vanessa said. “He just looked annoyed. Like I’d ruined something. And he said, You know how it is, Van. Men get bored after that many years. You should have seen it coming.” She stared into her tea. “You should have seen it coming. Like it was my fault. Like I’d failed some test I didn’t know I was taking.”
“It wasn’t your fault,” I said.
“It felt like my fault,” she said. “It felt like I’d gotten old and boring and he’d gone and found somebody better. And Kristen…” She stopped. “Kristen wasn’t sorry either. She called me a week later. She said, I’m sorry it had to happen this way, Van, but you can’t stop love.“
She put her face in her hands.
“After the divorce, I moved into that condo downtown. And I just sat there. For months. Thinking about how I’d been the one who got left. The boring one. The one who should have seen it coming.” She lifted her head. “And I decided I was never going to be that person again. I was never going to be the wife who gets left. I was going to be the other one. The one who takes.”
She looked at me.
“And then I moved in here,” she said. “And you came over with a pie. And you helped me unpack my kitchen. And you were so nice.” Her voice broke. “And I hated you for it. Because you were exactly who I used to be. You had a sweet husband and a good life and a nice house, and you brought pies to strangers. And I thought, She doesn’t even know. She doesn’t know how fast it can all go away.“
Please click the Continue Reading button below to keep reading.
Comments (0)