My divorced neighbor told me, “I’m going to steal your husband, so you might as well start preparing for divorce…
“Why didn’t you tell me?” I asked.
He sat down next to me on the bed.
“Because I didn’t want to make you feel bad,” he said. “I knew what she was doing. I’m not an idiot, Jan. I’m goofy, but I’m not an idiot. But I thought if I told you, you’d be upset, and you’d worry. And I didn’t want you to worry. So I just kept saying no. And I kept putting everything in the shoebox. In case.” He swallowed. “In case you ever needed to know I wasn’t hiding anything.”
“In case,” I repeated.
“I’m a chemist,” he said. “I keep records. It’s a sickness.”
I laughed. Through my tears. I couldn’t help it.
He took the shoebox off my lap. He put it on the floor. He took both my hands in his.
“Janet,” he said. “Look at me.”
I looked at him.
“Seventeen years,” he said. “You want to know what I think when I look at you in the morning? When you’re standing in the bathroom in that old blue robe?”
I couldn’t speak.
“I think, There she is,” he said. “That’s what I think. Every morning. There she is. The girl I spilled wine on. The woman who held my hand when the doctor told us about the miscarriage. The woman who sat with her mother for two years and never once complained. The woman who ate spaghetti four nights a week and made it taste like a party.” His voice cracked. “The woman who raised the smartest, most eye-rolling daughter in Ohio. That’s who I see. I’m not bored, Jan. I’m the luckiest man on this whole street.”
I started crying again. Harder this time. He pulled me against his chest and held me.
“You’ve got eleven gray hairs,” he said into my hair.
“You counted?”
“I’m a chemist,” he said. “I count things.”
So the question wasn’t Irvin anymore.
The question was Vanessa.
I lay awake for a long time that night after Irvin fell asleep. Thinking.
I thought about going over there and screaming at her. Telling her to stay away from my husband. Calling her every name I knew.
I thought about calling the police. But she hadn’t done anything illegal. Being a terrible person isn’t a crime.
I thought about telling the other neighbors. Making sure everybody on Willowbrook Lane knew exactly what kind of woman she was.
But every time I thought about it, I kept coming back to something else.
That box in her garage. With DUMP written on the side in angry black marker.
And the white wedding album with the gold letters, sitting on the high shelf in my closet behind my winter sweaters.
Vanessa & Mark. June 14, 2008.
I got out of bed. I went to the closet. I reached up and took it down.
I sat on the floor of the closet with a flashlight and opened it.
I’d never looked inside before. It didn’t seem right. But now I did.
The first page was a photo of a young woman in a white dress. Long dark hair. A big, real smile. She was standing in front of a church, laughing, with her head tipped back. She looked about twenty-nine. She looked so happy.
It was Vanessa. A younger Vanessa. A Vanessa I’d never met.
I turned the pages. Vanessa and a tall man with sandy hair cutting a cake. Vanessa dancing with an older man, probably her father. Vanessa with her bridesmaids. Vanessa and the sandy-haired man, Mark, kissing at the altar.
On the last page, there was a photo that wasn’t from the wedding. Somebody had slipped it in later. It was a picture of a backyard barbecue. A sunny day. A group of people at a picnic table. Vanessa and Mark, older now, maybe late thirties. And next to them, a blond woman. Pretty. Laughing. With her hand on Mark’s arm.
On the back of the photo, in faded pencil, someone had written: Us & the Carlsons. Labor Day 2019. Best neighbors ever!
I looked at the blond woman’s hand on Mark’s arm.
I looked at it for a long time.
And I thought I understood.
I called my friend Denise the next day.
Denise works at the county courthouse. She knows how to look things up. Public records. Divorce filings. That sort of thing.
“I need to know about a divorce,” I said. “Vanessa and Mark. Last name might be Hale. Finalized maybe six or eight months ago. Franklin County.”
Denise called me back two hours later.
“Vanessa Hale and Mark Hale,” she said. “Final in November. It’s public record, so I can tell you what’s in the filing.” She paused. “Janet, why are you asking?”
“Just tell me. Please.”
“The grounds are listed as adultery,” Denise said. “On his part. He was having an affair. For about two years, according to the filing.” She paused again. “With a neighbor. A woman named Kristen Carlson. Next door. Married too. Her husband filed for divorce the same month.”
I closed my eyes.
“There’s more,” Denise said. “There’s a statement from Vanessa in the file. About how she found out. You want me to read it?”
“Yes.”
Denise read it.
I came home early from a sales trip. Kristen’s car was in my driveway. They were in our kitchen. When I confronted Mark, he said, “You know how it is, Van. Men get bored after that many years. You should have seen it coming.”
I sat very still.
Men get bored after that many years.
You should have seen it coming.
Vanessa hadn’t said those words to me because she believed them.
She’d said them because someone said them to her.
The invitation came three days later.
It was a card. Cream-colored, with little blue flowers around the edge. It was in our mailbox, addressed only
toIrvin Morrison. Not to Irvin and Janet. Not to the Morrisons. Just Irvin.
You’re invited! Summer BBQ at Vanessa’s. Saturday, August 3rd, 4 p.m. Food, drinks, fun. The whole neighborhood is coming! Can’t wait to see you there. — V.
Irvin showed it to me at the kitchen table. He was frowning.
“The whole neighborhood,” he said. “She invited the Pratts and the Johnsons and the Kowalskis. I asked. Everybody on the street got one.” He tapped the card. “Everybody but you.”
“I see that.”
“I’m not going,” Irvin said. He pushed the card away. “I’m not going to a party you weren’t invited to. That’s ridiculous.”
I looked at the card for a long time.
Then I smiled.
“Actually,” I said. “I think you should go.”
He stared at me.
“Jan—”
“Go,” I said. “Be nice. Be polite. Eat her potato salad. Talk to the neighbors.” I picked up the card and looked at the little blue flowers. “And half an hour after it starts, I’m going to come over.”
“You weren’t invited.”
“I know,” I said. “That’s sort of the point.”
Irvin looked at me for a long moment. He’s known me for seventeen years. He knows when I’ve made up my mind.
“What are you going to do?” he asked carefully.
“I’m going to bring the hostess a gift,” I said.
“What kind of gift?”
I told him.
He was quiet for a long time. Then he took off his glasses. He rubbed his eyes.
“That’s either the meanest thing I’ve ever heard,” he said, “or the kindest. I genuinely can’t tell which.”
“Me neither,” I said. “I guess we’ll find out.”
I spent the next week getting ready.
I went to the craft store and bought a big white gift box. The kind with a lid that comes all the way off. And a roll of wide blue ribbon. The same blue as the flowers on her invitation.
I asked Irvin for the shoebox from the garage. He brought it to me without asking why.
I took out every single thing. The notes. The printed text messages. The stale cookies in their ziplock bag. The unopened bottle of wine. The chemistry book in its bookstore bag with the receipt.
I put them in a large clear plastic bag. I sealed it.
Then I went to my closet. I took down the white wedding album with the gold letters. Vanessa & Mark. June 14, 2008.
I wiped the dust off the cover with a soft cloth.
I wrapped it in white tissue paper.
And on Saturday morning, the day of the barbecue, I got up early. Before Irvin. Before Maddie.
And I baked a pie.
Peach. My grandmother’s recipe. With a lattice top and a little cinnamon in the filling. The same pie I brought her the day she moved in.
When it came out of the oven, I let it cool on the windowsill.
Then I wrote a card.
It took me a long time. I wrote it three times before I got it right.
The barbecue started at four.
From our kitchen window, I could see over the fence into Vanessa’s backyard. She’d gone all out. Strings of little white lights hanging from the trees. A long table with a white tablecloth. Coolers full of beer and wine. A big grill with smoke rising from it. Music playing from a speaker. Some kind of soft jazz.
The neighbors started arriving at four-fifteen. The Pratts, from across the street, who’d lived on Willowbrook Lane for forty years. The Johnsons, with their three little boys. Mr. and Mrs. Kowalski, who were in their eighties and walked very slowly. A young couple from the end of the street I didn’t know well. About twenty-five people total.
Irvin went over at four-twenty.
I watched from the window. He was wearing his good khakis and a blue button-down shirt. No socks and sandals. I’d made him change.
Vanessa saw him come through the gate.
Her whole face lit up. She put down her wine glass and walked straight across the yard to him. She was wearing a red sundress. Short. Low-cut. Her hair was loose and curled.
She threw her arms around his neck and hugged him. Too long. Way too long.
Irvin stood there with his arms at his sides. He didn’t hug her back. He patted her shoulder once, awkwardly, like you’d pat a dog you didn’t know very well.
Then he stepped back.
She took his arm. She led him around the yard, introducing him to people he’d lived next to for fourteen years. Holding his arm the whole time. Laughing at everything he said.
I watched her bring him a beer. I watched her touch his chest. I watched her stand very close to him at the grill, so close their shoulders were touching.
I watched the neighbors notice. Mrs. Pratt raised her eyebrows at Mrs. Johnson. Mrs. Johnson looked at her husband. Mr. Kowalski frowned.
Irvin kept stepping away. Every time she got close, he took a step back. Every time she touched his arm, he found a reason to move. To get a plate. To talk to Mr. Kowalski. To go check on the Johnson boys by the fence.
But she kept following.
At four-fifty, Maddie came into the kitchen. She stood next to me at the window and watched for a minute.
“Wow,” she said. “She’s really going for it.”
“She is.”
“Are you okay?”
“I’m okay,” I said. I picked up the white gift box with the blue ribbon. “I’m going over.”
Please click the Continue Reading button below to keep reading.
Comments (0)